Yes they would . I was just at a craft show with a few sets last weekend and I had a lady with normal size hands try them on and they fit fine. She did not try the hat on but even by just looking at them together the hat looks bigger then the other girl knit ones. These are also double layered in the gloves. The other girl sets are just one layered. Both cute and both work but the fuzzy ones did cost a little more to buy, they are warmer and a little bigger but are sold as one size fits all girls