Honestly, I dont know anything about either one. Check the measurements of both on line, and see if they are close. I can check on my daughters Touch later today. But, she just left, so it would be way later today. Unless my other daughters Touch is here... OK... Too tall (vertically) for a 1st gen Touch, anyway. Lol! Looks like would be fine across. But, about 1/2 inch or so up and down. Sorry! =)